Wind energy penetration in the transmission networks has been steadily increasing during the last decades. This situation causes integration problems with the electrical grid.
Regarding the power converter, these problems can be classified as follows:
- Working with very low SCR or quality factor grids: the resonance frequency of the harmonic filter decreases and can destabilize the current control loop.
- Sub-synchronous resonances: when series capacitors used in long transmission lines interact with the converter control loops, resonances at low frequencies appear.
- Parallel resonances: the use of capacitor banks on a wind farm level can have an influence on the system stability.
An accurate modelling of the converter control loops and its interaction with the grid becomes indispensable in order to overcome these challenges. Using SIL and HIL systems meet this requirement, but these systems are time-consuming. The modelling of the control loops, grid, and generator systems as linear time-invariant (LTI) models, instead, allows high agility to run parameter sweeps and test new algorithms.
The LTI model allows to express the whole system (grid + control + generator) as one state-space matrix. The stability and dynamic behaviour of the system can be obtained easily from the LTI model.
The non-linearities of the system (converter switching, non-linear control algorithms…) must be linearized or eliminated.
The following workflow is proposed to anticipate grid interaction problems:
- Characterization of all possible casuistics of a grid: parameter variations (e.g. number of turbines connected), network branches connected or disconnected, capacitor banks connected or disconnected.
- Generation of LTI models of all possible grid, generator and control algorithm casuistics to analyze the control loops behavior and obtain the set of parameters or new algorithms to assure the good performance.
- Validation of the solution using SiL and HiL systems.
Generation of LTI models
LTI model of a certain grid, LTI model of a certain converter control option and LTI model of a certain generator are combined to form an LTI model associated to a particular grid, control and generator combination.
Validation of LTI modelling
Despite simplifications (no switching and dead-time, linearization of non-linearities), the LTI model replicates with sufficient precision the current response measured in real test-bench.
Obtaining an optimized control structure
Low time (~100 ms) is needed to generate and analyze one LTI system. That brings the possibility to test high number of different control parameters and algorithms with all possible different grid and generator combinations, obtaining stability maps and dynamical behaviours.
The optimal control structure and its parametrization are selected, which are stable with all possible grid and generator casuistic and present best dynamical behaviour.
Validation of the control structure
The selected control structure and its parametrization are validated with SiL & HiL simulation platforms together with an automated testing procedure, to eliminate uncertainties due to simplifications and linearization of the control algorithms when generating the LTI model.
The use of LTI models is proposed to anticipate complex network issues. These LTI models are generated to each particular grid, generator and control algorithm and parameter casuistics, allowing to check in a fast way the stability and the dynamic behaviour of the whole system.
Simplifications must be done in order to generate the LTI models. Switching and dead time are neglected, and non-linear control algorithms must be linearized. In spite of these simplifications, the LTI model and real system responses have a good equivalence.
Through simulation sweeps using LTI models, an optimal control structure can be selected, that assures stability with all possible grid and generator casuistics and has acceptable dynamical behaviour.
The selected control structure and its parametrization is finally validated using SiL / HiL simulation platforms. In this way, the good performance of the selected control structure is totally guaranteed.
Velasco, J. Lopez, “Discrete-Time Domain Modeling of DQ-Frame Current-Controlled Systems through easy Implementation,” 2018 IEEE 19th Workshop on Control and Modeling for Power Electronics (COMPEL), Padua, 2018, pp. 1-7.
Velasco, “Modelización de parques eólicos conectados a redes débiles,” 2019. PhD thesis, Public University of Navarre, Pamplona, Spain.
Harnefors, X. Wang, A. G. Yepes and F. Blaabjerg, “Passivity-Based Stability Assessment of Grid-Connected VSCs—An Overview,” in IEEE Journal of Emerging and Selected Topics in Power Electronics, vol. 4, no. 1, pp. 116-125, March 2016.
Dong, B. Wen, D. Boroyevich, P. Mattavelli and Y. Xue, “Analysis of Phase-Locked Loop Low-Frequency Stability in Three-Phase Grid-Connected Power Converters Considering Impedance Interactions,” in IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, vol. 62, no. 1, pp. 310-321, Jan. 2015.
Lorea, J. Aguirrezabal, “Development of INGECON® WIND LV Power Converter for DFIG topology Wind Turbines up 5.X MW, ” Wind Europe, 2019.
M. Maciejowsky, “Mutlivariable feedback desing (1. edition). Boston, USA. Pearson Education, 1989.
Kukkola, M. Hinkkanen, K. Zenger, “Observer-based state-space current controller for a grid converter equipped with an LCL filter: Analytical method for direct discrete-time design,” IEE Trans. Ind. Appl. 51, 4079-4090, 2015.
Li, J. Fang, Y. Tang, X. Wu, Y. Geng, “Capacitor-voltage feedforward with full delay compensation to improve wead grids adaptability of LCL-filtered grid-connected converters for distributed generation systems,” IEE ETrans. Power Electron. 33, 749-764, 2018.
Zhang, X.F. Wang, F. Blaajberg, W.S. Wang, C. Liu, “The influence of phase-locked loop on the stability of single-phase grid connected inverter,” Proceedings paper presented on IEEE Energy Conversion Congress and Exposition. Montreal, Canada. 4737‐4744, 2015.
Xabier Juankorena, R&D Engineer of Ingeteam Wind Energy
David Velasco, Control, Software & DFIG Regulation Engineer of Ingeteam Wind Energy
Iker Esandi, Control and Software Senior Engineer of Ingeteam Wind Energy
Eduardo Burguete, R&D Engineer of Ingeteam Wind Energy
Ingeteam is an international technological Group specialized in electric power conversion. Its state of the art developments in power and control electronics (inverters, frequency converters, controllers and protections), rotative electric machines (Indar motors, generators and submersible motor&pumps sets), systems (electromechanical engineering and automation projects), and services (operation & maintenance services), enables it to provide the best solutions in different sectors, namely: wind, solar PV, hydro and fossil fuel power generation; metal and mineral processing; mining; marine; rail traction; waters; e-vehicle charging and power grid automation, always achieving sustainable and efficient energy generation, transmission, distribution and consumption. The company operates throughout the world, and is permanently based in 22 countries, with a headcount of 4,000. R&D is the backbone of its business activity, in which 5% of its turnover is annually invested.