Windpower Engineering & Development

  • Home
  • Articles
    • Most recent posts
    • News
    • Featured
  • Resources
    • U.S. offshore wind projects
    • Digital issues
    • Podcasts
    • Suppliers
    • Wind Power Videos
    • Wind Power Events
  • Webinars
  • Videos
  • Subscribe
    • Enewsletter Subscription
    • Magazine Subscription
  • 2022 Leadership in Wind
    • 2021 Winners
    • 2020 Winners
    • 2019 Winners

Report: O&M costs headed up

By Paul Dvorak | February 2, 2012

O&M costs for wind power are far higher than originally projected, particularly in the U.S., now the world’s largest wind power market, says Wind Energy Update. .

A trend line suggests O&M costs actually go up over the time period of consideration, especially when considering new data as a result of this survey. This is also supported from anecdotal data suggesting an increasing trend in wind O&M costs. Scatter is also observed with the Lawrence Berkley National Lab data, confirming that the variability of the new O&M cost data is not new.

Additional survey data contained cost estimates for wind turbine O&M costs per MW installed per year. These values were $40,000 (€28,000) per MW per year, with a standard deviation from the mean of $12,000 (€8,500). Among the anecdotes pulled from interviews was the observation that in the 2002 to 2003 time frame O&M costs had been estimated at $15,000 to $20,000 per 1.5 MW unit, but instead the true cost average is $40,000 to $50,000 per unit per year, after warranty. Another source estimated O&M expenses at $40,000 per 2MW unit, with $1.5 million per unit being the worst-case scenario.

A summary of primary findings on O&M cost trends derived from a series of confidential interviews includes these observations:

• O&M costs for wind power are far higher than originally projected, particularly in the U.S., now the world’s largest wind power market.

• A particular turbine operating reliably in Germany at a less than 20% capacity factor may experience catastrophic failures in the U.S. operating at a 35% capacity factor, due to more rigorous wind resource regimes.

• The U.S. wind resource results in much higher power production at far lower end-use power costs, but at the expense of often unaccounted O&M costs, an issue that has been largely “under the radar” due to warranty coverage.

• Europe’s premium power prices allow for more preventative maintenance and, therefore, overall lower maintenance costs than the U.S. Also in the U.S., annual power production is down 2 to 5% if compared to European turbines when resource factors are accounted for.

The chart plots frequency of survey responses to $/kWh.

• The U.S. has, on average, lower availability than Europe. This fact appears to be a reflection of better O&M service arrangements in Europe, a theme explored further in the next report section.

• Problems with gearboxes and blades throughout the global wind-power industry peaked in 2007 to 2008, though major retrofits will be necessary in the coming years.

• O&M challenges with gearboxes, generators, drive trains and blades have been virtually universal across major brands – though there are a few exceptions with recent upgrades and success stories.

• New direct-drive turbines – the latest design fad – may provide a key O&M solution since they eliminate the gearbox. Hybrid direct-drive/gearbox systems could serve as a bridging technology, much like gas-electric hybrids transformed the auto market.

Component and Sub-Assembly: Data Results and Analysis

An accompanying chart summarizes data for annual failure frequency for various components and sub-assemblies. Annual failure frequency is the inverse of the mean-time between failures for various components and sub-systems.

Data suggests that electrical systems are still the most frequent component or sub-assembly to fail, which was largely confirmed by confidential interviews. These electrical systems consist of myriad components, including breakers, relays, and switching contacts.

Wind Energy Update
www.windenergyupdate.com


Filed Under: News, O&M, Offshore wind

 

About The Author

Paul Dvorak

Tell Us What You Think!

Related Articles Read More >

California sets goal of 5 GW of offshore wind by 2030
City of Cleveland
Ohio grants permit for six-turbine project in Lake Erie, 10 miles off the shore of Cleveland
wind turbines
Evergy purchases 199-MW Oklahoma wind farm for $250 million
Avangrid to be O&M lead on Vineyard Wind 1 offshore project

Podcasts

Wind Spotlight Interview: RAD Torque Systems
See More >

Windpower Engineering & Development Digital Edition

Digital Edition

Browse the most current issue of Windpower Engineering & Development and back issues in an easy to use high quality format. Clip, share and download with the leading wind power engineering magazine today.

Windpower Engineering & Development
  • Wind Articles
  • Solar Power World
  • Battery Power Tips
  • Subscribe to Windpower Engineering
  • Advertising
  • About Us/Contact Us

Copyright © 2022 WTWH Media LLC. All Rights Reserved. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of WTWH Media
Privacy Policy | Advertising | About Us

Search Windpower Engineering & Development

  • Home
  • Articles
    • Most recent posts
    • News
    • Featured
  • Resources
    • U.S. offshore wind projects
    • Digital issues
    • Podcasts
    • Suppliers
    • Wind Power Videos
    • Wind Power Events
  • Webinars
  • Videos
  • Subscribe
    • Enewsletter Subscription
    • Magazine Subscription
  • 2022 Leadership in Wind
    • 2021 Winners
    • 2020 Winners
    • 2019 Winners