Wind turbines, like helicopters, are fatigue machines—always vibrating and working to loosen their fasteners. More vibration will come as engineers develop longer blades to capture more wind energy and build towers that reach higher. These increased vibration levels may also loosen some tower fasteners. To prevent this, engineers are looking for better ways to measure tension (rather than torque) and prevent corrosion. Finally, fastening companies are becoming more wary of costs especially as they count toward total cost of ownership.
Torque control is just one way to achieve sufficiently consistent pretension in structural bolts. It all comes down to the k-factor, the relationship between the torque applied to a fastener and the actual tension reached in the bolt. K-factors range from 0.10 to 0.20.
Consider also the variability of torque tools. Actual bolt tensions vary ± 40% or more, according to one study, when using torque control to generate a precise load. Crews may find a better tension indicator in a direct-tension indicator that squirts. It’s a washer that tells when a target tension had been reached in a bolt, regardless of the applied torque. When the bumps on the washer sufficiently compress, a brightly colored silicone squirts from cavities under the bumps. The compression tolerance of the bumps and squirt appearance are calibrated to a required tension. GL certifies that the devices for M36, M42, and M48 bolts will reach target tension ±10%.
Other construction trends deal with ways to keep bolts tight. The spokesman for a locking disc manufacturer says a locking washer can eliminate fastening failure. The device consists of two preassembled washer-shaped pieces that have inclined cams on one side and a series of radial ridges on the other. The cam sides are placed between the nut and joint material. The cam angle is greater than the bolt-thread-pitch angle, so the interlocking cams and non-slip ridges of the washer jam to prevent the nut from loosening under vibration.
Lighter and smarter wrenches are another bolting trend. While hydraulic wrenches and bolt pullers have been a mainstay in the wind industry, electric wrenches are attracting attention because of distinct advantages.
For instance, one wrench manufacturer says the margin for torque error is a lot less with an electric wrench because the tools can be “locked” to a particular torque value. Manufacturers of electric wrenches say they work with ±3% accuracy. In addition, some wrenches allow setting different torque limits at one time to be applied to different jobs.
In addition, more bolting work asks for accountability – knowing that each bolt is tightened to a prescribed level. More wind turbine manufactures require proof that each bolt has been installed and maintained at the appropriate torque specs to maintain the manufacturer’s warranty. Recent electric torque wrenches allow collecting such data. On-board data loggers report how many bolts have been torqued along with failed torques and over torques. Also, one project manager estimates that electric torquing takes about 33% less time than does hydraulic torquing.
The manager adds that the calibration and testing capabilities exceed those of the hydraulic torque tools. Electric wrenches can allow digitally tracking all torque testing. When testing the electric wrench, test data transfers to a program that logs it in a format that can be manipulated to fit one needed for tower manufacturers’ specifications.
A few electric torque wrenches also let users tighten bolts to a torque or an angle. This simplifies work on GE rotors, says one engineer. For example, the tool could be set to 350 Nm plus 120°. Once bolt tightening begins, the gun automatically torques the bolt to 350 Nm, stalls for a moment, and then moves the nut 120°. This is vital to some torque procedures because it lets techs torque in a continuous motion without stopping to rely on someone’s eye to add the 120°. WPE
Filed Under: News, Turbines
Onkar Singh says
Fully endorse views of Ken. These are real issues needing urgent corrective action. Very little has been done by Wind Turbine Industry to mitigate the recurring suffering of technicians who have to hold bulky tools in inconvenient positions to complete their job. It is high time some Turbine Manufacturer collaborates with tool manufacturers in addressing this issue. Or even some of the major associations connected with Wind Turbine manufacturing and Servicing can take this up.
Sorry, this is all old news, like two years or older.
The real news will arrive when inventions for torque or tension don’t require holding a 45lb + electric torque gun over your head for hours. (A GE 1.6/100 has 940 bolts to toque not counting the 140 odd base bolts – try doing that in a day.). All the tools are way too heavy.
Now how about those outside blade bolts (bearing to hub) on the GE machines? With no platform to stand on, no handles, no waist or chest high anchors, (just the paper towel size tie-off rail you are also standing on like a ballerina) and no access to the front of the nose cone, these machines add a new dimension to “high flying acrobatics” … oh yeah, now add the torque gun – which by the way are designed with no lanyard connection points whatsoever – , a long, fat electric/data cord and loads of grease on everything.
Lighter tools are needed along with safe access to these bolts..
If your interested in pics I have plenty.